Further reading
Resources
Everything we used, and everything we know of that a researcher on this subject would want — gathered so that the next person who wants to hear these women does not have to start from nothing. The section that matters most is the journals, diaries and biographies of the wives themselves: the places where their own voices are actually held. Links were checked on the build date at the foot of the page; tell us at mormonstories@gmail.com if one has rotted.
Start with these four
If you read nothing else, read these. Between them they contain almost everything that has been published about the fifty-five women.
-
"Determining and Defining 'Wife': The Brigham Young Households" Jeffery Ogden JohnsonDialogue - A Journal of Mormon Thought 20:3 (Fall 1987), pp. 57-70, Table 1 at pp. 65-71
The only comprehensive published list of Brigham Young's wives, and the spine of this site. Names, marriage dates, birth and death years, prior husbands. Johnson's own conclusion is worth reading in full - that most of these women took part in the church for the rest of their lives, which "tends to dispel the myth of the horrified woman, enslaved against her will." Free to read from Dialogue's own archive.
-
Brigham Young: Pioneer Prophet John G. TurnerHarvard University Press, 2012The standard modern biography, and the best single book on the man. Chapter 5 covers the Nauvoo marriages. Note what it does not contain: no appendix of wives, no list. Endnote 56 (pp. 441-42) naming the fifteen women legally married to other men is its only published roster.
Buy it AmazonBookshop.orgRead free
-
In Sacred Loneliness: The Plural Wives of Joseph Smith Todd ComptonSignature Books, 1997Not about Brigham Young - but it is the model for the book these women still do not have, and eight of Joseph Smith's widows are also on Brigham Young's list, so chapters 3, 4, 13, 18 and 25 are directly relevant.
Buy it AmazonBookshop.orgRead free
-
Nauvoo Sealings, Adoptions, and Anointings: A Comprehensive Register of Persons Receiving LDS Temple Ordinances, 1841-1846 Lisle G. BrownThe Smith-Pettit Foundation / Signature Books, 2006Who received which ordinance, on which day, with which proxy. The document behind most of the "sealing type" column on this site. Pages 350-53 cover Brigham Young.
Buy it AmazonBookshop.org
The two projects this site is modelled on
One gave the women biographies; the other put a whole evidentiary record on the open web for free. This site is trying to do both for Brigham Young's fifty-five.
-
Joseph Smith's Polygamy (josephsmithspolygamy.org) Brian C. Hales
A free, public, document-by-document reference on Joseph Smith's plural marriages, with a page for each woman, timelines and the sources attached. The direct model for this site. Hales writes as a believing Latter-day Saint and much of the site answers critics; this site is neither apologetic nor counter-apologetic, and takes no position on whether any of it was inspired. What we take from him is the method — sourced, free, public, checkable, organised around the women one at a time — not the posture.
-
Joseph Smith's Polygamy, 3 volumes Brian C. HalesGreg Kofford Books, 2013The scholarship behind the website. Volume 1 covers the history, volume 2 the doctrine, volume 3 the theology; Don Bradley did much of the documentary research for volume 1. Read alongside Compton, who reaches different conclusions from a good deal of the same evidence.
Buy it AmazonBookshop.org
Further books
-
The Mormon Hierarchy: Origins of Power D. Michael QuinnSignature Books, 1994 - Appendix 6Counts 56 wives, keeping Maria Lawrence. Also the source for several children counts and will markers used here.
Buy it AmazonBookshop.org
-
The Mormon Hierarchy: Extensions of Power D. Michael QuinnSignature Books, 1997 - chapter 5
-
Brigham Young - American Moses Leonard J. ArringtonAlfred A. Knopf, 1985The previous standard biography, by the Church's own historian. Gentler than Turner and still valuable on the Utah administration.
Buy it AmazonBookshop.org
-
Mormon Polygamy: A History Richard S. Van WagonerSignature Books, 2nd ed. 1989Buy it AmazonBookshop.org
-
The Complete Discourses of Brigham Young Richard S. Van Wagoner (editor)The Smith-Pettit Foundation, 5 vols., 2009
Fuller than the Journal of Discourses, which only ever printed a selection. The right place to check a quotation.
-
Sally in Three Worlds: An Indian Captive in the House of Brigham Young Virginia KernsUniversity of Utah Press, 2021
On Sally (Kahpeputz) Young Kanosh, the Pahvant Ute girl brought into the household in the late 1840s and frequently misdescribed as one of his wives. She was not. Why that matters.
Buy it Bookshop.org
-
Wife No. 19, or The Story of a Life in Bondage Ann Eliza YoungDustin, Gilman & Co., 1875The nineteenth-century bestseller by the wife who left him, sued him and toured against him. Written to destroy him and read for 150 years as though it were the only wife's voice available. Public domain; scans are on the Internet Archive.
Buy it Bookshop.orgRead free
-
Isn't One Wife Enough? The Story of Mormon Polygamy Kimball YoungHenry Holt, 1954A sociologist's study, and a great-grandson's. Dated, but full of family material.
Buy it Bookshop.org
Articles and chapters
-
"Adoptive Sealing Ritual in Mormonism" Jonathan A. StapleyJournal of Mormon History 37:3 (2011)
The clearest modern account of the law of adoption - the ritual that explains the strangest rows in this data. What adoption was.
-
"Emily Dow Partridge Smith Young on Trial: The Chicago Interview, 1892" H. Michael MarquardtJournal of Mormon History 34:3 (2008)
One of the disputed marriage dates on this site turns on this article. The disagreement.
-
"Brigham Young Genealogy" Susa Young Gates and Mabel SanbornUtah Genealogical and Historical Magazine vol. 11 (July 1920), p. 131
The family's own list, compiled by his daughter and granddaughter. The reason Quinn keeps Maria Lawrence on the roster when Johnson drops her.
-
"The Law of Adoption: One Phase of the Development of the Mormon Concept of Salvation, 1830-1900" Gordon IrvingBYU Studies 14:3 (1974)
Published lists of the wives
There are fewer of these than anyone expects. This is the entire set we know of; tell us what we have missed.
-
Johnson, Dialogue 20:3 (1987), Table 1
55 wives. Comprehensive. The spine of this site.
-
Quinn, Origins of Power, Appendix 6
56 wives - Johnson's list plus Maria Lawrence.
-
Turner, Pioneer Prophet, endnote 56 (pp. 441-42)
Not a list of wives. A list of the fifteen women who were legally married to other men at the time of their sealing. Frequently mistaken for a roster.
-
Gates and Sanborn, "Brigham Young Genealogy" (1920)
The family's own compilation, and the earliest of these.
-
Dean C. Jessee's editorial work on the Brigham Young papers
Drops Maria Lawrence, agreeing with Johnson.
-
This site's table
Johnson's 55 with every subsequent correction applied and every disagreement flagged. Available as JSON for anyone who wants to build on it.
Scholars on Brigham Young
Living and dead. If you are looking for someone to write the book, this is roughly the field.
-
John G. Turner George Mason University - livingAuthor of the standard modern biography. A frequent guest on the Brigham Young Podcast.
-
TCTodd Compton Independent historian - living
Author of In Sacred Loneliness. The model for what is being asked for here.
-
BHBrian C. Hales Independent historian - living
Author of Joseph Smith's Polygamy (3 vols) and builder of josephsmithspolygamy.org, the free public document archive this site is modelled on. Writes as a believing Latter-day Saint; how we differ.
-
JSJonathan A. Stapley Independent historian - living
On ritual, adoption, sealing and Latter-day Saint liturgy.
-
JD
-
HMH. Michael Marquardt Independent researcher - living
Documentary work on Nauvoo marriages and their dating.
-
LBLisle G. Brown Marshall University - living
Compiler of the Nauvoo temple ordinance register.
-
JJJeffery Ogden Johnson Archivist - made the only comprehensive list, 1987
-
Leonard J. Arrington 1917-1999Church Historian, founder of the "New Mormon History", author of American Moses.
-
DQ
-
RW
-
EC
-
Lindsay Hansen Park Independent historian - livingCreator of Year of Polygamy, the series that showed what telling these women's lives one episode at a time can do.
Podcast episodes
Mormon Stories and the Brigham Young Podcast have covered this material at length. The Brigham Young Podcast works through Turner's biography chapter by chapter with Turner himself.
-
The Brigham Young PodcastThe full series with John G. Turner, chapter by chapter through Pioneer Prophet. Chapter 5 is the Nauvoo marriages.
-
Mormon Stories PodcastTwo decades of interviews, many touching polygamy and its aftermath.
-
Year of PolygamyLindsay Hansen Park's series on the wives of Joseph Smith and the broader history of Mormon polygamy. The model for the podcast this site is asking someone to make.
Read the sources yourself
Everything in this block is free to read online and was checked on the build date at the foot of this page. Where a publisher's own page could not be verified, the link goes to a copy that could - a guessed publisher URL is worse than no link at all.
-
Journal of Discourses, 26 volumes (1854-1886) Complete, free, volume by volume on the Internet Archive
Roughly 14,000 pages of Brigham Young-era sermons, including nearly everything on the quotes page. Volumes: 1 · 2 · 3 · 4 · 5 · 6 · 7 · 8 · 9 · 10 · 11 · 12 · 13 · 14 · 15 · 16 · 17 · 18 · 19 · 20 · 21 · 22 · 23 · 24 · 25 · 26. The official run ENDS at volume 26 in 1886; anything citing a later "Journal of Discourses" is citing something else.
-
Johnson's Table 1, the list this whole site rests on Dialogue - A Journal of Mormon Thought 20:3 (Fall 1987)
Free to read in full. If you read one thing from this page, read this.
-
Journal of Mormon History - the complete open-access run, 1974-2014 Utah State University Digital Commons
Eighty issues, every one free. Stapley on adoption is in vol. 37 no. 3; Marquardt on Emily Dow Partridge in vol. 34 no. 3.
-
BYU Studies - free archive
Derr on Brigham Young and Eliza R. Snow is in vol. 40 no. 2.
-
Wife No. 19 (1875), complete Ann Eliza Young
The only full-length published autobiography by any of the fifty-five, and a hostile one. Why that matters.
-
The Church's own account of sealing
Including the 1894 revelation that ended adoption sealings. Where this site's reading differs, it says so rather than implying agreement.
-
Church History Catalog
The finding aid for the Brigham Young office files and the Nauvoo ordinance records. Start here if you are doing original research.
-
The Joseph Smith Papers
The documentary edition, free and complete, for the Nauvoo period and the 1843 revelation.
Archives and databases
-
Church History Library, Salt Lake City
Holds the Brigham Young office files and the Nauvoo ordinance records.
-
Dialogue - A Journal of Mormon Thought
Johnson's 1987 article and table are free to read in the archive.
-
The Joseph Smith Papers
For the Nauvoo period and the 1843 revelation.
-
Internet Archive
Public-domain scans of Wife No. 19, the Journal of Discourses and much else.
-
FamilySearch
Genealogical records for most of the fifty-five. We have not yet linked person ids from here; doing so is on the list.
-
Find a Grave
Burial records and, for many of these women, the only photograph in circulation. Also not yet linked here.